When a Casting Beats Machining from Solid
A part machined from bar or billet is easy to buy. There is no tooling to pay for, the drawing can change next week, and any capable machine shop can make it. You pay for that convenience in material and spindle time, because most of the stock you buy leaves the machine as swarf.
At some annual volume, a casting that arrives close to its final shape becomes the cheaper route. This article shows how to find that point for your own part, what else changes when you convert, and when machining from solid remains the right choice.
Where the money goes when you machine from solid
The cost of a machined part has three components: the stock you buy, the time on the machine, and the credit you receive for swarf.
- Stock. You pay for the whole bar or billet, including the metal that is cut away. The ratio of stock weight to finished weight is the first number to check. A housing with a deep bore or thin walls can use three to five times its own weight in stock.
- Machine time. Roughing removes most of that surplus metal and often takes the larger share of the cycle, especially in stainless steel.
- Swarf. The chips have scrap value, but it is a fraction of the bar price.
All three scale with the amount of metal removed. The more the part differs from the shape of the bar, the more you pay for metal you do not keep.
What a casting changes
A casting is poured close to the final shape, so you buy little more metal than the part contains. Machining is then limited to the faces that need it: bores, sealing faces, threads and datum features. A machining allowance of a few millimetres is left on those faces, and the rest of the part stays as cast.
The price of this is tooling. Each casting process needs a pattern or die made for your part, paid for once before the first casting is poured.
| Material machined today | Usual casting route | Tooling |
|---|---|---|
| Stainless or carbon steel bar | Lost wax investment casting | Wax injection die |
| Aluminium billet | Gravity die casting, or high pressure die casting at high volume | Steel die |
| Steel or iron bar, larger parts | Sand casting in ductile or grey iron, where the design allows the change of material | Pattern and core boxes |
ISO 8062-3 sets the tolerance grades and machining allowances each process can hold. Those values decide which faces you must still machine.
The break-even sum
The conversion pays once the saving per part has repaid the tooling.
Break-even quantity = tooling cost ÷ (cost per part from solid − cost per part as a casting)
The example is a real quotation of ours. The part is a 316 stainless steel fitting that weighs about 1 kg finished and needs roughly 3 kg of round bar. We quoted it machined from bar, and as a lost wax investment casting with the functional faces machined. Prices are shown as an index, with the price per part machined from bar at 100.
| Order quantity | Machined from bar | Investment cast, then machined |
|---|---|---|
| 20 | 100 | 66 |
| 40 | 100 | 60 |
| 60 | 100 | 58 |
| Tooling, paid once | none | 1,820 |
At 60 off the casting saves 42 per part, so the tooling is repaid after 44 parts. A first order of 60 is already 12% cheaper with the tooling included.
The enquiry held twelve parts. Nine were cheaper as castings, most by about a fifth, and three stayed machined from bar. The stock ratio alone does not decide the result: a housing that needed about five times its finished weight in bar saved 23%. The machining that remains after casting matters as much as the metal removed.
What you gain beyond cost
A casting also removes limits that the cutting tool places on the design.
- Shape. Curved internal passages, ribs, bosses and varying wall thickness cost little extra in a casting. Milled from solid, each one adds cycle time.
- Fewer parts. Several machined pieces that are bolted or welded together can often become one casting, with fewer joints and fewer leak paths.
- Material choice. Cast grades exist for most wrought grades, and some conversions open a cheaper material. A steel housing can become ductile iron where the loads allow it.
- Machine capacity. Shorter cycles release spindle hours for other work.
When machining from solid stays the better route
A casting is the wrong answer in several common cases.
- Low volume and prototypes. The tooling never pays back on a handful of parts.
- A design that is still changing. Each revision can mean a tool modification and new samples.
- Wrought properties are required. Cast alloys generally give lower ductility and fatigue strength than the wrought equivalent, and properties vary with section thickness. Check the cast grade against your design allowables before you commit.
- Tight tolerances on every surface. If every face must be machined anyway, most of the saving disappears.
- Small turned parts. A simple part turned from bar on an automatic lathe is hard to beat.
- Time. Tooling, samples and approval take weeks, and delivery by sea adds more. If you need parts next month, machine them.
Conversion also carries one-off costs beyond the tooling: first article inspection, any pressure or non-destructive testing, and your own approval of the new route. Add them to the tooling figure when you run the sum.
How to spot a conversion candidate
A part is worth costing as a casting when most of these are true. They are rules of thumb, and the calculator gives the answer for your figures.
- The stock weighs more than about three times the finished part.
- Roughing takes up most of the cycle time.
- The design is stable and has several years of demand ahead.
- Annual volume is in the hundreds or more. High pressure die casting needs thousands.
- Only a few faces carry tight tolerances.
- The part has pockets, passages or curved forms that are slow to mill.
- It is assembled from several machined pieces that could be one.
Run the sum on your own part
The break-even calculator takes two quoted prices, or a build-up from weights and machining times, together with the tooling cost and annual volume. It returns the cost per part on both routes, the break-even quantity and the payback time.
For a quotation we need the 3D model and drawing, the material specification, the annual volume, and any test or certificate requirements. Our guide on what to include in a casting RFQ lists the details. If the conversion goes ahead, the design guides for investment casting and gravity die casting cover draft, wall thickness and tolerances.
Send us your drawing and specification and we will return a budgetary quotation within three working days.
Get a Quote More ArticlesSources and further reading
ISO 8062-3, Geometrical product specifications: dimensional and geometrical tolerances and machining allowances for castings. EN 10213 and EN 10283, steel castings for pressure and corrosion resistant service. EN 1706, aluminium casting alloys. EN 1563, spheroidal graphite cast irons. Always work from the current edition.